Saturday, November 22, 2014

Effect of cooking on vegetable fiber, Matthee and Appledorf, 1978

Matthee, V., & Appledorf, H. (1978). Effect of cooking on vegetable fiber. Journal of Food Science43(4), 1344-1345.

Investigate the effect of cooking on dietary fiber and moisture content of vegetables. There are 3 periods looked at: raw, short cooked (15-20 min) and long cooked (45-50 min). Vegetables studied were broccoli, carrot, cabbage, and okra. Moisture content increased across all vegetables except broccoli which decreased. Weight loss has previously been attributed to the collapse lignocellulose walls with subsequent extrusions of cellular fluids. Broccoli seemed to have the most variation in dietary fiber during cooking periods due to the formation of indigestible residues during cooking which are isolated together with lignin. The authors suggest that because all NDF values were higher than CF values that CF is not a good indicator of overall fiber present that NDF values should replace the existing CF values found in food tables. NDF = cellulose, hemicellulose and lignin. ADF= cellulose and lignin. Changes between NDF and ADF reflect changes in cellulose alone because hemicellulose and lignin were generally unaffected by cooking. Overall ADF and for the most part CF and cellulose seemed to increase after cooking. Cellulose may increase because it might either have been liberated from the surrounding material or hydrolyzed during cooking process. 

My thoughts in relation to our study: How do our NDF and ADF analyses affect the amount of fiber available for analysis? If cellulose can be made more available after heating/ cooking, are we overestimating the amount of fiber available for human consumption?

                        Broccoli         Carrots        Cabbage     Okra
NDF           incr same amt incr only long     na             incr only long
ADF           incr all            incr all              not disc        incr all
Cellulose  incr same amt incr only long    incr all         incr only long
Hemicellulose   na            na                      na              na
CF              incr all            incr all               incr all        incr only long
lignin          incr only long na                       na              na

Dietary Fiber: analysis and food sources, Southgate 1978

Southgate, D. A. T. (1978). Dietary fiber: analysis and food sources. The American Journal of Clinical Nutrition, 31: S107-S110.
Dietary fiber is derived from two sources: plant cell walls and nonstructural polysaccharides (gums and mucilages) that occur naturally in food or as food additives (gums, algal polysaccharides and modified celluloses). It is a mixture of components dependent on types of food in diet. Composition of cell wall is dependent on stage of maturity of plant and the cultural conditions with which the plant was grown. Author suggests that crude fiber isn’t a good indicator for effects on physiology and the identifying the individual components of fiber is necessary. He analyzes foodstuffs down to polysaccharide species. Discusses extraction rates of cereals and how they are positively affiliated with amount of dietary fiber, thus inversely related to digestibility. This is interesting as the lower the extraction rate, the more digestible a product; however, the fibrous aspect of the foodstuff may be the person’s end goal to promote colon health.